Albama Arkansas Auburn Florida Georgia Kentucky LSU Mississippi State Missouri Ole-Miss USC Tennessee Texas A&M Vanderbilt
Latest News

Much Ado About Something That Goes On Every Week

man-with-binocularsSignal-stealing.  The grand no-no of sports.  The type of skullduggery that only a genuine nogoodnik would engage in.

Well, yeah.  That or everybody frickin’ does it.

In case you missed it over the weekend, current Alabama assistant director of player personnel Tyler Siskey was caught on camera using binoculars — apparently — to try and swipe Ole Miss’ signals as they were being relayed onto the field.  Siskey, you see, is a former assistant coach under Mississippi’s Hugh Freeze.

 

Ole Miss / Alabama 2013: Siskey sells out Freeze

 

A number of Rebel fans are now crying “Cheater!” and demanding an SEC inquiry.  Those folks are way, way off base.  (And I would say the same regardless of the teams involved… for all you who’ll claim I must be a big ol’ Bama fan.)

First, signals are stolen all the time.  There’s a reason so many coaches bury their faces in playsheets when speaking.  They’re not only worried about sign-stealing, they’re worried about lip-reading.  Schools also have multiple people sending in signals with some doing so for dummy purposes.

Second, knowing that Siskey had switched sides, you can be sure that Freeze and crew changed their signals for Saturday’s game.  And if they didn’t, that’s on them.

Third, I would bet you that Freeze and Ole Miss have at some point tried to steal a sign or two from some other team at some point.  Again, if no one’s doing it, why do coaches hide their mouths behind those giant laminated call sheets?

And fourth, if the SEC were to investigate, it would become a much, much bigger issue.  Think Spygate.  Conspiracy theorists claim that the New England Patriots cheated their way to three Super Bowl victories.  That’s because the NFL wanted to make sure Bill Belichick followed the edict they sent to every team: “No taping signals with video cameras.”  But in sending that message, the NFL caused itself a much bigger headache.  (Interestingly, the Belichick’s winning percentage post-Spygate is better than it was pre-Spygate.)  No one ever stopped to think that while it’s illegal to steal signs with a camera, it’s legal — because technically it’s unstoppable — to have a guy with binoculars and a note pad gather the exact same information.  The NFL made it a major issue.  Then it became a game-tarnishing issue because no one knew what was being discussed and everyone wants to believe they’ve been cheated (see: Ole Miss fans today).

If the folks in the SEC league office are wise, they won’t go anywhere near this one.  Any investigation would become an overblown issue in the age of social media and wall-to-wall ESPN coverage.  Also, there’s no way for the SEC to keep an eye on everyone in a stadium who is using binoculars.  (It’s a certainty that schools would start sending “plain clothes” sleuths into the stands to stare down the opposing sideline.)

The correct play here is to let the schools of the SEC handle sign-stealing by changing signals and covering mouths.  It’s part of the game.

If you don’t grasp that, tell Santa and Ms. Clause I said hello.

 

UPDATE — If you don’t like my take, here’s another from an ex-college assistant.  Warning: He sees things the way I do.

 


6 comments
j_scott_o
j_scott_o

I agree with you 100% on this stealing signals stuff...pretty much word for word.  However, I do want to ask (or point out) isn't this almost the same logic you used to rail against supporters of Johnny Manziel and the whole autograph scandal and his extra curricular activities this summer?  You know, the "everyone is doing it" meme?

Ag In FM
Ag In FM

Go read read the CBS article about the game preparations of A&M the week of the Bama game. The Monday of that week, Sumlin walks into the offensive meeting and tells  the coaches that he had received word that the Aggie offensive signals were being deciphered. He then simply tells the coaches to change the signals, end of discussion. There was no ranting about cheating or filing protests. It's part of the game plan, always assume that your signals are being studied.

RealBillOakley
RealBillOakley

@MrSEC OM hired a Malzahn assistant over Summer. OM plays AU this week. Betcha OM fans don't realize that.

ColonelRodimus
ColonelRodimus

It's not so much the signal stealing that should be examined.  Yes, that has many of us ticked off but like you said it goes on all the time.  The inquiry needs to be into whether or not Alabama is in violation of NCAA rule 11.7.2.1 which defines who can and cannot coach the team.  Neither article mentions what the rule book says.  If you are not the head coach, one of the 9 assistants, or one of the 2 GA's you cannot help coach the team in any capacity whether it be in the stadium, at practice, or on the bus.  Siskey is none of the above and shouldn't have been in the box with binoculars deciphering what OM was trying to do on offense.

John at MrSEC
John at MrSEC moderator

@j_scott_o 

First, if you could please link me to a story where I "railed against supporters of Johnny Manziel," I'd like to see it, because I don't remember doing so.  Could be wrong, I write a lot of stuff every day, but I don't think I wrote anything that would be called "railing against" A&M supporters.

The difference -- and it's a clear one -- is that some (not all and not the majority) Texas A&M fans started naming other players in an effort to show that Manziel shouldn't be picked on.  That's throwing other players under the bus and trying to create problems for other schools just "because."  It's a common childish tactic.  "Well, what about him?"  I'm not big on people trying to implicate other individuals when doing so would have zero impact on their own issues in the first place.

No one at Alabama -- to my knowledge -- has posted photos or videos of Auburn coaches or Kentucky coaches swiping signals just to show that others have done the same thing (though I'm sure some have tried to dig some up).  

And for the record, if the SEC or the NCAA decide to investigate Alabama over this matter, we'll say the same thing we did about Manziel -- Everybody may be doing it, but your the only ones the "authorities" are looking into.  Fair or not.

Another difference -- and again, it's a big one in our view -- is that everybody really does steal signals.  Why do you think coaches hide their faces and mouths whenever they call a play?  Everybody does not, however, sign thousands of autographs in a single sitting.  Some others might do it, but it's definitely not as common as sign-stealing.  Not even close.

Further, sign-stealing isn't even an NCAA violation, to my knowledge.  Selling autographs (or failing to stop others from profiting from your likeness) very much IS a violation.  That's why Manziel was eventually slapped on the wrist with a one-half suspension.  

The closest rule this Alabama issue comes to violating is Bylaw 11.7.2.1 which states: "No individual other than coaches designated to fill the coaching categories set forth in Bylaw 11.7.2 may participate in any manner in the coaching of the intercollegiate team of a member institution during any football game, practice or other organized activity."  Whether or not Siskey's actions violated this rule is open for debate.  Was he "coaching" while simply looking at the opposing sidelines through binoculars?  No.  If the definition of coaching is working with the players -- and that's how we'd take it -- absolutely not.  Ole Miss fans would argue that coachin' is coachin' but this rule was instituted to prevent schools from hiring specialists to work with their players.  It wasn't put in place -- to my knowledge -- to prevent other university personnel from providing an extra set of eyes to the actual coaches from a pressbox location.

As you can see, I view the two incidents as being wholly unrelated.  Here's hoping you don't feel that I just railed against you.

Thanks for reading the site,

John

Trackbacks

  1. Chat Line says:

    Emerging Management Planning

    Appreciate it for helping out, good info.

  2. Sites we Like…

    [...] Every once in a while we choose blogs that we read. Listed here are the latest sites that we choose [...]…

  3. Souls in the Waves

    Very good Early morning, I just stopped in to go to your web site and imagined I would say I loved myself.

  4. Title

    [...]Here is a superb Blog You might Discover Exciting that we Encourage You[...]

  5. submit articles, submit free article pro blogging

    is the method that many people are using to make incomes from home. blogging is a fairly new model that allows people to correspond with others basically for happiness or if you are a skilled blogger like me, as a way

  6. is important to plan and use time

    management wisely in order to give yourself sufficient time to proofread. the following tips have helped me improve communications over the years:1. avoid proofreading when you are hungry, tired, or angry (walk away from the paper) 2. use your word pro…

  7. urlman cow says:

    Thorn of Girl

    Excellent data may be discovered on this website weblog.

  8. Title

    [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a handful of unrelated data, nevertheless actually really worth taking a appear, whoa did one particular study about Mid East has got extra problerms also [...]

  9. age of instant everything, we expect to

    find easy remedies for bad habits.unfortunately, there really aren’t any quick fixes for bodily abuse. you didn’t end up overweight and flabby overnight and the problem isn’t going to get fixed without that old fashioned stand-by called effort. but,…

  10. pdr-training says:

    pasta, a salad for starter and fruits

    for dessert.3. what is good post exercise food?the type of food that you eat right after weight training will have a huge impact on how well and fast you build muscles. nutrition is important to help your body recover from the

  11. fast cash advance companies

    Get information about fast cash advance companies on our site

  12. fast first american cash advance

    Get fast first american cash advance on my website

  13. other advantage that i believe blogspot has

    is that it seems to get indexed faster than the wordpress blog hosted on wordpress.the shared advantage of wordpress and blogspot is that they are both free. in this day and age, that alone has to be a huge plus when

  14. to have lost our focus on content,

    and instead, trust in vague systems of traffic generation, and care about ad placement as a means to increase conversion ratios. and yes, a well-placed ad is better than a horribly placed one, but the fact still remains, keyword research and

  15. sufficient inspiration. however, it is extremely essential

    to hang in there and not get disheartened.many writers stay focused on particular topics and create a niche for themselves in a particular genre. there are still others who write on each and every genre and do not restrict themselves to

  16. site is yours and cannot be taken

    down.i have also noticed that wordpress tends to rank better on google. i’ve had dozens of posts show up on the front page of google, when blogger sites are nowhere to be seen.blogger or wordpress: when to use eachi personally believe

  17. let’s take a look at another blog

    traffic source that is free and that can get you tons of visitors:2) viral marketingviral marketing is the process of having multitudes of people spreading the word about your blog. the easiest way to start a viral marketing campaign is to

  18. cool site says:

    the internet.also, when you get your blog,

    you will want to insert your google adsense ads on it. and blogger makes it easy for you to integrate it onto your blog. this might be the fastest way to start your own internet business… aside from using affiliate programs.

  19. sure to make these clear to your

    chosen professional. if you are keen on promoting your website using ethical, cost-effective and quick means, the best way to ensure quality traffic to your website is to hire the best seo article writer for creating original, keyword rich website cont…

  20. Superb website

    [...]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get a lot of link love from[...]…

  21. check pr

    Among me and my husband we have owned additional MP3 gamers through the years than I can count, like Sansas, iRivers, iPods (traditional & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I’ve settled down to one line of gamers.

  22. Title

    [...]usually posts some extremely interesting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]

  23. Title

    [...]one of our visitors just lately advised the following website[...]

  24. Title

    [...]please check out the sites we adhere to, like this a single, because it represents our picks from the web[...]



Follow Us On:
Mobile MrSEC