Albama Arkansas Auburn Florida Georgia Kentucky LSU Mississippi State Missouri Ole-Miss USC Tennessee Texas A&M Vanderbilt
Latest News

Writer: Cut Garcia Some Slack

South Carolina quarterback Stephen Garcia has been suspended for the fourth time since arriving in Columbia.  Word broke of the latest disciplinary action last evening.  The suspension supposedly was a school decision involving USC’s president, AD Eric Hyman, and Steve Spurrier.

Hearing this news — and the word via multiple sources that Garcia’s actions were once again tied to alcohol — many sites (including this one) suggested that Carolina should finally move on from its oft-troubled senior signal-caller.

But South Carolina writer Phil Kornblut tosses out a “not so fast” to those of us who believe the time has come for Spurrier to make Connor Shaw his quarterback and his team’s leader.

Here’s what Kornblut wrote today for the SportsTalk Radio Network:


Give Garcia a break on this one.  Without going into all the details, I am confident enough to write in this space that I think Garcia, in this case, is as much a victim of his past than of anything new he’s done.

From what’s been told to me about what happened with Garcia at the gathering Tuesday night, I find it hard to believe he was given a suspension.  And based on the reaction from a number of his teammates, they support him totally.  It’s pretty amazing that after all the travails Garcia has been thru (sic), he still has the support of the lockerroom.  And even though he said he was part of the suspension decision, I’m not convinced Steve Spurrier agrees with the decision.

Garcia will now be skewered in the media, locally, regionally and nationally.  This is where his past haunts him.  And I am by not means trying to defend what he’s done before this.  I’m just saying that in this case, based on what I know, the punishment is a little over the top.


So let’s get this straight:


1.  Garcia has gotten into trouble on numerous occasions.

2.  Carolina has welcomed him back after each screw-up.

3.  Most in the media — this site included — have given him a pass for those screw-ups.

4.  Garcia has been suspended again.

5.  Most in the media — this site included — have finally stopped defending him, saying it’s time for Spurrier to change quarterbacks.

6.  And it’s at this point that someone else in the media writes that his anonymous sources are telling him that Carolina officials are to blame for this mess… not Garcia.


Is that about the gist of it? 

If it turns out Carolina has overreacted and left Garcia hanging out to dry — knowing darn well that his history would work against him in the press — then Hyman, Spurrier and the lot of USC’s administration deserve a swift kick in their collective rear.

So here’s the question: Why was Garcia suspended? 

Carolina officials likely won’t answer that, but it’s a question they need to be peppered with repeatedly until they do speak.

 


5 comments
Richard
Richard

The reality is FIVE SUSPENSIONS. If Garcia cannot control himself when words are being hurled at him how will his decision making skills be any better when SEC linemen are hurling themselves at him?.

Gamecock in Tulsa
Gamecock in Tulsa

At some point, even the slightest violation can't be excused.

In basketball, you are allowed to make 4 fouls with a 5th foul resulting in ejection. They don't say..."well that 5th foul was an inadvertant hand-check on a stationary point guard 39 feet from the basket, so he can remain in the game." The say: "That's a foul on whomever. It is his 5th and he has fouled out of the game. What a silly decision made by that player 39 feet from the basket."

It's time to move on. I hope Garcia can turn his life around and be a positive influence on the world. He seems like a fairly good kid, but has never understood the rules applied to him.

whygee
whygee

Cut him some slack?

I don’t care if he got busted for murder or for jaywalking, when you’re on a fine line, you walk it.

This, “well, THIS time it really wasn’t so bad,” excuse is just that, an excuse. So after four suspensions, which in and of itself is laughable and arguably inexcusable, for our 5th year senior quarterback, one of which he just got back from and “guaranteed” we had seen the last of his mishaps, we should cut him some slack?

And what’s this “based on what I know,” stuff? Why not tell us what you know instead of asking us to take your word for it? It’s like the boy who cried woof. Regardless of the severeness of what he did last night, the fact is our 5th year senior QB is suspended for the 5th time.

Maybe after 4 times, it doesn’t really take a whole lot to bring more punishment.

Signed,
A lifelong Carolina fan

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Latest Bama News 4/7/11 WRITER: CUT GARCIA SOME SLACK Homepage | MrSEC.com Reply With Quote + Reply to [...]



Follow Us On:
Mobile MrSEC